Welcome to Stefano's Pizzeria (New York Style), where the essence of authentic New York pizza comes alive right in the heart of Warsaw, NY. Nestled at 12 N Main St, this pizzeria has become a beacon for pizza lovers seeking that perfect slice — characterized by a delightful crispy crust, rich cheese, and a subtly tangy sauce that resonates with the roots of classic New York pizzerias.

From the moment you step in, the aroma of freshly baked pizza greets you, evoking memories of bustling streets in New York. Customers rave about the signature pizza, describing it as “solid crust” that’s “super cheesy,” a testament to Stefano's commitment to quality. The pizzeria’s daily robust volume of pizza and subs showcases its popularity and continuous stream of satisfied diners.

The appetizer selection at Stefano's is not to be overlooked. Devour the Garlic Knots — they’ve even garnered mentions for being “awesome,” providing a playful start to your meal. Other mouthwatering options include Fried Cauliflower and Onion Rings, each bringing a satisfying crunch that pairs perfectly with the offerings of pizza or subs.

For those looking for something heartier, the range of subs and wraps is a highlight. The Chicken Finger Sub is particularly noteworthy; one satisfied customer proclaimed it as “hands down, one of the best” they’ve ever had, expertly balancing tender chicken and a soft roll, leaving diners yearning for more.

Although the ambiance may not steal the spotlight — described as somewhat dark and dreary by patrons — the true star here is undoubtedly the food. Many have traveled long distances, only to stop for a quick take-out, leaving with a smile and satisfied taste buds, as one comment notes, “it was great.”

If you find yourself in the vicinity, treat yourself to a visit at Stefano's Pizzeria. With a diverse menu that caters to both pizza aficionados and those craving hearty subs, it promises an unforgettable dining experience. Don’t just take our word for it; come and see why this hidden gem continues to rise in the ranks of pizzerias in Western New York!